Wrongful trading is a claim a liquidator or administrator can bring against you personally once your company has failed. It looks at what happened after you knew, or ought to have concluded, that the company couldn’t avoid insolvent liquidation or administration.

If your company is behind with its bills, you’ll want to know whether carrying on puts your own house and savings at risk. Being insolvent doesn’t put them at risk on its own. Trading while insolvent isn’t against the law in itself, and a company can fall behind for a while and still recover. The risk begins later, when recovery is no longer realistic and the company keeps taking on debt anyway.

Wrongful trading isn’t a crime, so the claim itself can’t lead to prison. It’s a civil claim, decided by a court. An order is usually measured by how much worse things got for creditors after that point, not by every debt the company owes. You also have a defence if, from then on, you did all you should have done to keep the creditors’ losses down.

Deciding whether to keep a struggling company going is a hard call, because you’re making it on figures that change from week to week. Stopping too soon can close a business that might have pulled through. The law recognises that, which is why it judges you on what you knew, or should have seen, at the time.

If you ask us whether you’ve crossed that line, we start with the management accounts and bank statements for the last three months. Those are the papers a liquidator would use to fix the date.

Key Takeaways

  • Trading while insolvent isn’t unlawful in itself. Liability starts later, once a careful director in your role would have seen that the company couldn’t be saved.
  • Only the liquidator or administrator can bring the claim, or someone they assign it to. Limited liability doesn’t protect you from the order.
  • There’s a single defence in the Act. It asks whether, from that point, you took every step you ought to have taken to minimise creditors’ potential loss.
  • Fraudulent trading is different. It needs an intent to defraud, and it’s also a crime with a maximum of 10 years in prison.
  • A court that finds you liable for wrongful trading can also disqualify you as a director for up to 15 years.

What Is Wrongful Trading Under UK Law?

Wrongful trading is a civil claim, not a criminal offence. It only exists once the company is in insolvent liquidation or insolvent administration. Fraudulent trading is the criminal version, under section 993 of the Companies Act 2006. Section 213 of the Insolvency Act also gives the liquidator a separate civil claim for it.

Only the liquidator or the administrator, known as the office holder, can bring a wrongful trading claim. Section 246ZD lets them sell or hand on the claim, or the money it brings in, to someone else. That’s how a claim can still be pursued when the company has no money to fund it. A creditor can’t bring the claim in their own name unless it’s been assigned to them.

The test is in section 214(2) of the Insolvency Act 1986. A court can make an order against you only if all three of these are true:

  1. The company has gone into insolvent liquidation. That means its assets aren’t enough to pay its debts, its other liabilities and the costs of the winding up.
  2. Before the winding up began, you knew or ought to have concluded there was no reasonable prospect of avoiding insolvent liquidation or administration.
  3. You were a director of the company at that time.

Section 246ZB applies the same test where the company goes into insolvent administration, and there the administrator brings the claim. Even when all three conditions are met, you can still rely on the defence in section 214(3), set out further down.

“Ought to have concluded” is where most of the argument happens. The court measures you against a reasonably diligent person carrying out the same functions as you. Section 214(4) sets that as a minimum standard. It then raises the bar for a director who actually has more knowledge, skill and experience.

A director running a two-person building firm isn’t judged as the finance director of a listed group would be. Neither of them can plead inexperience as an excuse, though.

The standard covers the functions you were given, even if you never carried them out. So a director who left the finances to a colleague is still judged on them. It also covers shadow directors, people whose instructions the board was used to following. Each director is assessed separately, so one can be liable when another isn’t.

If the claim succeeds, the court orders you to pay such contribution to the company’s assets as it thinks proper. The amount is up to the court.

The court must be satisfied the company was worse off by the time of the liquidation (Re Marini Ltd). So if you kept trading but the losses didn’t grow, you may owe nothing.

Any money recovered doesn’t go to a lender with a floating charge, which is security over assets that change, such as stock. Section 176ZB of the Insolvency Act keeps it outside that charge. After costs, it goes to the preferential creditors, the ones the law pays first, which include HMRC for VAT and PAYE. What’s left goes to the unsecured creditors.

Courts do make these orders against real directors. In 2024 the High Court found two former directors of the British Home Stores chain liable for wrongful trading and misfeasance. Misfeasance is a breach of duty that costs the company money.

When Does Wrongful Trading Liability Begin?

Wrongful trading liability begins on what’s usually called the knowledge date. That’s the point at which a reasonably diligent director would have concluded the company couldn’t avoid insolvent liquidation or administration. Losses built up before that date don’t count against you for wrongful trading, while losses after it can.

Liquidators work out that date from the company’s own papers. They read the management accounts, cash flow forecasts, board minutes, bank statements and emails, looking for the moment the figures showed recovery was over. So the date can be fixed months earlier than you’d expect. The papers set the date, whatever you believed at the time.

The warning signs are mostly ordinary ones. You top up the account from your own money so that a supplier payment clears. You agree a time to pay arrangement with HMRC to clear tax arrears in instalments, then need a second one. One customer makes up 60% of turnover and orders less each quarter. Your accountant starts asking whether the company can keep going for the next twelve months.

One of the first things I check is when a director first put their own money in to cover a bill. It’s often the earliest dated sign that cash was short.

None of those signs settles the point on its own, and the knowledge date is rarely one dramatic day. It’s more often the weight of several bad signs that a careful director would have read together. Carrying on in the hope that things turn round, without changing how decisions are made, is the pattern a liquidator looks for.

The Supreme Court described the directors’ duties to creditors that come before this in the Sequana case in 2022. Under section 172 of the Companies Act 2006, you must start giving weight to creditors’ interests at a certain point. That’s once you know, or should know, that the company is insolvent or close to it, or that an insolvent liquidation or administration is probable.

That weight grows as the position gets worse, until the creditors’ interests come first. If you ignore that shift, a liquidator can bring a misfeasance claim. Wrongful trading is a separate claim that starts later.

GOV.UK’s guidance for directors of insolvent companies puts the same duty in practical terms. You should protect the company’s assets, treat all creditors the same and avoid making their position worse. That applies whether the company is still trading or has stopped.

What Is the “Every Step” Defence to Wrongful Trading?

The “every step” defence in section 214(3) of the Insolvency Act is the only statutory defence to wrongful trading. The court can’t make an order if it’s satisfied that, after the knowledge date, you took every step you ought to have taken.

Those are steps with a view to minimising the potential loss to the company’s creditors. The court judges them on the assumption that you knew the company couldn’t avoid insolvent liquidation or administration.

The bar is high, but it’s judged by what a reasonably diligent director in your role would have done at the time. It isn’t judged with hindsight. In practice, the steps that carry weight are the ones that leave a dated record:

  • Take advice from a licensed insolvency practitioner early. A dated, minuted conversation shows the board looked at the position with someone qualified to judge it. It also fixes a point from which every later decision can be explained.
  • Hold board meetings more often, and minute the reasons. Meet weekly rather than monthly once the danger is clear. Minutes that record only the decision say nothing about how it was reached. Record the figures you looked at, the options you weighed and why you chose the one you did.
  • Keep a cash flow forecast you actually use. A 13-week rolling forecast, checked against what happened and used in board decisions, is far easier to defend. A 12-month plan that nobody compared with reality is much weaker.
  • Stop taking on credit the company can’t pay. This matters most for tax taken from wages and VAT collected from customers. HMRC has ranked as a preferential creditor for both since 1 December 2020. A liquidator will look closely at PAYE held back to keep the company going, although arrears alone don’t prove wrongful trading.
  • Write down why you’re carrying on. If you’re trading on because a funding round or a contract is close, record that reason and the date. Record what you’ll do if it falls through, too.

I’d rather see a short note written on the day than a long minute written up weeks later. A liquidator gives more weight to a record made at the time.

The court reads the papers to see whether creditors’ interests were really being weighed. It also looks at whether the board’s decisions changed once the position did.

What Happens if a Court Finds Wrongful Trading?

If a court finds wrongful trading, the main consequence is a contribution order. That’s a court order to pay money into the company for its creditors. Disqualification is a separate process. The two can run side by side, and you can face one without the other.

Contribution order. The court sets the amount it thinks proper, usually linked to how much the creditors’ position worsened after the knowledge date. The order is a court judgment. If it isn’t paid, it can be enforced against your property and income, and ultimately by a bankruptcy petition.

Disqualification after a finding. Section 10 of the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986 lets the court that finds you liable order director disqualification there and then. The ban can last up to 15 years, and the court can make it whether or not anyone asked it to.

Disqualification for unfit conduct. The wider route is section 6 of the same Act, after the Insolvency Service investigates for the Secretary of State. GOV.UK lists letting a company keep trading when it can’t pay its debts as an example of unfit conduct.

So you can face a disqualification case even where nobody brings a wrongful trading claim. A section 6 disqualification lasts at least 2 years and at most 15. The courts place bans in three bands. Less serious cases get 2 to 5 years, serious ones 6 to 10 and the most serious 11 to 15.

You can avoid a court case by offering the Insolvency Service a disqualification undertaking, which has the same effect as an order. Either way, you can’t act as a director, or help form, promote or run a company, without the court’s permission. Breaking a ban can mean a fine or up to 2 years in prison. It can also make you personally liable for the company’s debts.

Compensation orders. Since 2015, sections 15A to 15C of the Act have let the Secretary of State ask the court for a compensation order. It makes a disqualified director compensate creditors who lost money because of their conduct.

Disqualifications are public. They appear on the Companies House register and on the Insolvency Service’s list of disqualified directors. Banks, landlords, insurers and future business partners can see them for as long as the ban lasts.

How Is Wrongful Trading Different From Fraudulent Trading and Misfeasance?

Wrongful trading is one of several claims a liquidator can bring over how a company was run before it failed. These four are the easiest to confuse, because they can turn up in the same case.

ClaimStatuteTestConsequence
Wrongful tradingInsolvency Act 1986, s.214 / s.246ZBNo reasonable prospect of avoiding insolvent liquidation or administration, and a failure to take every stepCivil only. Personal contribution order. Disqualification possible under s.10 of the Company Directors Disqualification Act.
Fraudulent tradingInsolvency Act 1986, s.213 (civil) / Companies Act 2006, s.993 (criminal)Intent to defraud creditorsCivil contribution order, criminal liability up to 10 years’ imprisonment, or both.
MisfeasanceInsolvency Act 1986, s.212Breach of duty or misuse of company assetsCivil. Restoration, repayment or compensation.
Preferences and undervalue transactionsInsolvency Act 1986, ss.238, 239Preferring a creditor, or transferring assets at an undervalue, within the look-back periodCivil. The transaction is reversed.

The central difference is dishonesty. Fraudulent trading needs proof that the business was carried on with intent to defraud creditors. Wrongful trading needs no dishonesty at all, only a failure to act once the outcome was clear. That makes it the easier of the two to prove.

A misfeasance claim can be brought alongside it. Misfeasance looks at money taken out or misused, while wrongful trading looks at the decision to keep trading.

Wrongful Trading After COVID-19 and Crown Preference

Wrongful trading has applied in full since 1 July 2021. The Corporate Insolvency and Governance Act 2020 suspended liability for losses from 1 March to 30 September 2020. Later regulations suspended it again from 26 November 2020 to 30 June 2021. Those suspensions have ended, and they don’t cover any trading after 30 June 2021.

Since 1 December 2020, HMRC has been paid before ordinary creditors for taxes the company collects for it. This is Crown preference, introduced by the Finance Act 2020. Those taxes are VAT, PAYE income tax, employee National Insurance, student loan deductions and Construction Industry Scheme deductions.

That matters for wrongful trading because unpaid PAYE and VAT are money the company collected on someone else’s behalf. Keeping it to fund trading loses money for a creditor with a protected place in the queue.

The arrears show plainly in the accounts a liquidator reviews, so they’re an obvious place to look when fixing the knowledge date. They’re evidence to weigh, not proof of wrongful trading on their own.

If PAYE is going unpaid so that wages can still go out, I’d treat that as the time to take advice. Keep a record of any time to pay arrangement, your reasons for carrying on and the advice you took.

What Should You Do If You Think You’re at Risk of Wrongful Trading?

If you think you’re at risk of wrongful trading, the steps that reduce your exposure are the ones that change what the company does next. They also leave a record of it.

  • Speak to a licensed insolvency practitioner before the next payment run. A first conversation is often free. It tells you where you’re likely to sit against the knowledge date and what needs to happen this week.
  • Stop and write it down. Pause any decision that adds to what creditors are owed. Write down what you’re doing and why, and date it. A liquidator rebuilds events from the paperwork, so a dated note now carries weight later.
  • Call a board meeting. Even if there are only two directors, hold the meeting. Minute the financial position and the decision taken.
  • Check where the company stands. Run the insolvency test for a quick read on the two tests in section 123 of the Insolvency Act. The cash flow test asks whether the company can pay its debts as they fall due. The balance sheet test asks whether its debts exceed its assets.
  • Don’t pay yourself or connected people ahead of other creditors. A liquidator can reverse preferential payments (section 239) and transactions at an undervalue (section 238). Payments to people close to the company carry the most risk. For a connected person, the law presumes the company meant to put them first.

The time limits for those claims differ. The periods run back from the start of the liquidation or administration. An undervalue can be challenged if it was made in the 2 years before, whoever received it. A preference to a connected person, such as a director or their family, can be challenged within 2 years. For anyone else, the limit is 6 months.

In each case the company must have been insolvent at the time, or become insolvent because of the transaction.

Be wary of an adviser who charges a monthly fee to “deal with” your creditors while you keep trading. Every week of trading after the knowledge date can add to the losses a court measures. The fee also comes out of money your creditors would otherwise have had.

Be just as wary of anyone who offers to take the company and its debts off your hands. Handing the company over doesn’t end your responsibility for how you ran it.

The earlier you take advice, the more options remain. Company administration, a company voluntary arrangement or a creditors’ voluntary liquidation can each keep more value for creditors than a compulsory liquidation. That’s the route a creditor forces with a winding-up petition. A company voluntary arrangement is a formal plan to repay creditors over time.

If you’re deciding whether to keep going at all, our guide on whether you can trade out of insolvency works through it.

Does Wrongful Trading Apply in Northern Ireland?

Wrongful trading applies in Northern Ireland under Article 178 of the Insolvency (Northern Ireland) Order 1989. Section 214 covers England, Wales and Scotland. Article 178 uses the same test and the same every step defence.

If the company trades in Northern Ireland, take advice from a practitioner who handles insolvency cases there. The procedure differs in places, even though the test is the same.

Your Next Step on Wrongful Trading Risk

If the company is struggling, being insolvent today doesn’t decide your risk. It turns on whether you can still show the company had a reasonable prospect of recovery. Every week of trading in hope after that point can make the eventual order larger.

You can do this much in an afternoon. Pull together the last three months of management accounts and bank statements. Book a confidential conversation with a licensed insolvency practitioner. Hold a minuted board meeting that records the position and the decision taken.

None of those commits the company to liquidation. All of them build the record that protects you later.

If you bring those papers to us, we’ll go through them with you and tell you where we think the knowledge date could fall. Talk it through with us before the next payment run.

FAQs on Wrongful Trading

Is wrongful trading a criminal offence under UK law?

Can creditors bring a wrongful trading claim directly?

How long can disqualification last for wrongful trading?

Are non-executive and shadow directors at risk of wrongful trading?

What if I genuinely believed the company could recover?

What happens if I cannot pay a wrongful trading contribution order?

Does professional advice supporting continued trading protect me?

Company Position Check

First, Check the Company’s Financial Position

This test does not assess your personal liability. It can help show how serious the company’s position may be and how quickly action could be needed.

Check my company’s position

Estimates are fineWe only call if you ask us to

Related Guides