Rescuing a business from insolvency means keeping the company, or at least its trade, going after it can no longer pay its debts. It’s usually done through a formal procedure run by a licensed insolvency practitioner.

So can an insolvent company be saved, or does it have to close? It can be saved if the business would make money once the old debts are dealt with.

Being insolvent doesn’t mean you have to close, and speaking to a licensed insolvency practitioner doesn’t commit you to closing either. In fact, the law makes rescuing the company the first aim of administration. A Company Voluntary Arrangement also lets the company keep trading while it pays creditors what it can afford.

It’s a hard decision. Staying open too long can leave you personally liable, while closing too early can throw away a business worth saving.

When a director asks me whether their company can be saved, I ask for one thing first. It’s a thirteen-week cash flow forecast that leaves out the old debts, such as the HMRC arrears. That shows whether the business itself still works.

Key Takeaways

  • Rescuing a business from insolvency is realistic when the trade would make a profit without its old debts. If it wouldn’t, a rescue procedure only buys time.
  • The main rescue routes are an informal deal such as HMRC Time to Pay, a Company Voluntary Arrangement and administration. Larger companies can also use a court-approved Restructuring Plan. A moratorium, a short legal pause on creditor action, can buy time first. Each route gives something up, whether that’s privacy, control or the company itself.
  • A Company Voluntary Arrangement (CVA) needs the support of creditors holding 75% by value of the votes cast. It still fails if most of the votes by value from creditors with no link to you or the company are against it.
  • Wrongful trading under section 214 of the Insolvency Act 1986 is the main personal risk for a director during a rescue. It’s the risk of carrying on trading once there’s no reasonable prospect of avoiding an insolvent liquidation or administration.
  • Don’t repay your own loan to the company, or anyone close to you, while it’s insolvent. A liquidator or administrator can ask the court to reverse it as a preference under section 239. The look-back is two years for connected people and six months for anyone else.

Rescuing a Business from Insolvency at a Glance

Quick Answer: Can You Rescue a Business from Insolvency?

Yes, if the business underneath still works. A company is insolvent if it fails either test in section 123 of the Insolvency Act 1986. Either it can’t pay its debts as they fall due, or its debts are bigger than its assets.

Failing either test still leaves rescue open. The routes are a CVA, administration, a Restructuring Plan or, where HMRC is the main creditor, an informal Time to Pay deal. Whether any of them works depends on the trade underneath, since a procedure only deals with the debt.

When Insolvency Rescue Is Realistic (vs When Liquidation Is Honest)

Rescue is realistic when the trading model still works. Take out the old debts, such as the bounce-back loan and the VAT arrears, and look at the next thirteen weeks. If the business pays its way on those figures, it’s a rescue candidate.

It’s a different story if the orders are shrinking, the margin has gone and customers are moving to cheaper rivals. In that case the honest choice is usually between a Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation now and a forced winding-up later. A Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation is the closure the shareholders start themselves, with a licensed insolvency practitioner as liquidator.

Main Director Risk During Insolvency Rescue

The main risk is wrongful trading under section 214 of the Insolvency Act 1986. It means carrying on trading after you knew, or should have concluded, that insolvent liquidation or administration couldn’t be avoided.

It’s a real risk but not an automatic one. A liquidator or administrator has to prove that point was reached, and that creditors lost more because you carried on. Trying a rescue on honest figures, with advice, isn’t wrongful trading in itself.

What to Do Next About Insolvency Rescue

In the next few days, get a written opinion from a licensed insolvency practitioner before you sign anything else. Record the board’s decisions in minutes, and stop any payments to yourself or connected companies.

Then choose the procedure with the practitioner, not before. Our page on business recovery services explains what instructing one involves. If you’d rather talk it through first, contact us.

Free Online Test

4 questions · 2 minutes

How Serious Is Your Company’s Position?

Answer four short questions to see how urgent the situation may be and which options could fit your company’s circumstances.

Check my company’s position

See your result online and receive a copy by email. We only call if you ask.

A laptop showing the first question of the insolvency test

What Does It Mean to Be Insolvent?

Insolvency Meaning (Cash-Flow vs Balance-Sheet Tests)

Section 123 sets two tests, and a company is insolvent if it fails either. The cash-flow test asks whether it can pay its debts as they fall due, including those due in the near future.

The balance-sheet test asks whether its liabilities are bigger than its assets. Liabilities here include debts that may arise later, such as the rest of a lease or a guarantee the company has given.

A company can fail the cash-flow test while its balance sheet still looks healthy. A profitable business that’s short of cash can be unable to pay on a Wednesday and fine again on Friday once a customer pays.

That’s why a company can drift into insolvency for weeks without anyone noticing. The duties that come with insolvency apply from the start, whether you’ve noticed or not.

Difference Between Insolvency and Recovery

Insolvency is a legal state. Recovery is what some insolvent companies go on to achieve, and some don’t.

Mixing the two up is risky, because it lets a board carry on as normal on the basis that “we’re not insolvent, we’re recovering”. If the company fails either section 123 test, it’s insolvent, however good the recovery plan sounds.

When Rescue From Insolvency May Not Be Suitable

Rescue isn’t the right call when the business loses money at its core or the customers have gone. Nor is it right when only fresh director loans keep it alive.

In those cases a CVA only spreads the same losses over several years. Meanwhile you’d be trading on in a company that can’t recover, which is exactly where wrongful trading claims come from.

How to Assess Whether Insolvency Rescue Is Possible

Viability Test for Insolvency Rescue

The test for viability is specific. Leave out the old debts and the deferred bills, then build a thirteen-week cash flow forecast for the business as it would trade without them.

The business is viable if it can pay its running costs, put something towards the old creditors and still keep a margin for surprises. If it only just covers its running costs, there’s nothing left to offer creditors, so no rescue deal will hold.

If the figures only work by leaving HMRC unpaid, I’d tell you plainly that it isn’t a rescue. HMRC can block a CVA if it holds enough of the debt, and it can present a winding-up petition.

Cashflow, Sale or Funding Evidence Needed

You’ll need a thirteen-week cash flow forecast naming who pays you and whom you pay. You’ll also need a list of creditors and a list of customers who owe you money. Bring copies of any personal guarantees too.

When a director brings us a rescue question, we ask for the creditor list early, split into HMRC, the bank, landlords and suppliers. The mix decides who can block a CVA vote and who’s likely to press for payment.

If a sale is possible, get a written valuation from someone who isn’t the buyer. A practitioner needs these papers before they can say whether the company has a future.

Creditor-Outcome Forecast Linked to Rescue

Every formal rescue is judged against what creditors would get if the company simply closed. A CVA proposal sets out that comparison before creditors vote.

In administration, the administrator must aim to rescue the company, or else get creditors a better result than a winding-up. A court will only force a Restructuring Plan on creditors who voted against it if they’re no worse off than in the likely alternative. Without that comparison, creditors have no reason to back the plan.

What Options Are Available for Insolvency Rescue?

The rescue routes fall into three groups, and the difference between them is what you give up. An informal deal costs least. A formal procedure gives up privacy, and administration gives up control or the company itself.

Informal Agreement or Repayment Plan

The informal route means negotiating directly with creditors. That’s usually HMRC, through a Time to Pay arrangement, plus a few suppliers who’d rather wait than lose the debt.

Informal deals are private, cheap and quick. However, they don’t bind anyone who refuses to join in, so they only work when the debts are limited and the main creditors agree.

Rescue or Restructuring Procedure

A Company Voluntary Arrangement is a deal to repay creditors over a fixed term, usually three to five years, while the company keeps trading. Once it’s approved, it binds every creditor who was entitled to vote, including those who voted against. It can’t take away a lender’s security, or HMRC’s priority for VAT and PAYE, unless they agree.

The standalone moratorium under Part A1 of the Insolvency Act 1986 protects the company from creditors for 20 business days while a rescue is planned. A licensed insolvency practitioner, called the monitor, must first state that a rescue is likely.

The directors can extend the moratorium once by another 20 business days. Longer extensions need creditors or the court, and a company facing a winding-up petition must apply to the court instead.

The Restructuring Plan under Part 26A of the Companies Act 2006 is the heaviest option. It’s a court process, so it suits larger companies with complicated debts more than most small firms.

Sale, Closure or Insolvency Procedure

When the business can’t carry on in its present company, the rescue moves to administration or a pre-pack sale.

Administration protects the company from creditors’ legal action under paragraph 43 of Schedule B1 to the Insolvency Act 1986. An administrator then runs the company, with saving it as a trading business as the first aim.

A pre-pack sells the business and assets, often to a buyer connected to the directors, straight after the administrator is appointed. Both routes take control away from you. Both can save the trade, the jobs and the goodwill, but the original company usually doesn’t survive.

ProcedureWhen It FitsWhat It SurrendersMain Director RiskRelated Guide
Time to Pay (HMRC)HMRC arrears only; the business itself pays its wayInterest keeps running, though agreeing the plan in time usually stops further late payment penalties; HMRC can cancel it if you miss a paymentPersonal liability notice for unpaid National Insurance if HMRC finds fraud or neglect by a directorTime to Pay HMRC
CVAThe trade works; enough creditors will accept less over timePrivacy: it’s on the public record for suppliers and credit agencies to seeA lender can still call in your personal guarantee; missed contributions end the CVACVA explained
Restructuring PlanLarger or more complex debts; groups of creditors who disagreeA court process with significant legal and adviser costsThe court must find the plan fair, and opposing creditors can challenge itBusiness restructuring
Standalone MoratoriumShort legal protection while a rescue is put togetherA payment holiday for most older debts, though wages, rent, new supplies and loan repayments must still be paid; a monitor oversees itThe monitor must end it if those debts go unpaid; they come first if liquidation or administration follows within 12 weeksInsolvency practitioner
AdministrationUrgent protection needed; a rescue or sale is possibleControl: the administrator runs the companyThe administrator’s report on your conduct, part of any insolvent company investigationAdministration explained
Pre-Pack AdministrationSpeed matters; goodwill would be lost; a buyer is readyThe original company; part of what unsecured creditors get backScrutiny of a sale to a connected buyer, including an evaluator’s report or creditor approval in the first 8 weeksPre-pack administration
CVL (last resort)No rescue route works; an orderly closure is the honest callThe company itselfThe liquidator’s report on your conduct; possible disqualificationLiquidation

The third column is the one to read, because every procedure gives something up. Choose the route that keeps what your business can’t do without. A CVA gives up privacy, administration gives up control, and a pre-pack or a CVL gives up the company.

What Risks Should Directors Watch During Insolvency Rescue?

Once a company is insolvent, or close to it, your duties change. Section 172(3) of the Companies Act 2006 keeps creditors’ interests in play. The Supreme Court confirmed in the 2022 Sequana case that you must then weigh them.

Once insolvent liquidation or administration can’t be avoided, creditors’ interests come first. Each risk in this table follows from that change.

RiskWhat Triggers ItConsequence
Wrongful Trading (IA 1986 s.214)Trading on after you knew, or should have concluded, that insolvent liquidation or administration couldn’t be avoidedA court order to contribute personally towards the extra loss to creditors
Preference (IA 1986 s.239)Paying one creditor ahead of others while insolvent, wanting to put them in a better position; the wish is presumed for connected peopleThe court can reverse the payment; the look-back is 6 months, or 2 years for a connected person
Transaction at Undervalue (IA 1986 s.238)Transferring assets for much less than their value within 2 years before the insolvency, while insolvent or becoming so as a resultThe court can reverse it, unless it was done in good faith for the business with reasonable grounds to think it would help the company
Personal GuaranteesThe company defaults on a bank, landlord or supplier debt you’ve guaranteedYou become personally liable for that debt, up to any limit in the guarantee
Personal Liability Notice (HMRC)Unpaid National Insurance contributions that HMRC says were due to fraud or neglect by a directorPersonal liability for those contributions; see our personal liability notices guide
Director DisqualificationA finding of unfit conduct after the liquidator’s or administrator’s report to the Insolvency Service under the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986A ban of 2 to 15 years from acting as a director or managing a company without the court’s permission
Misfeasance (IA 1986 s.212)A breach of duty that cost the company moneyA court order to repay or contribute to the company’s assets

These risks often arrive together. A liquidator who finds a preference will also ask what else was paid out. A lender can call in a guarantee as soon as the company defaults.

None of them is automatic, however. Each needs a claim or a finding against you, and the time to reduce them is before a formal procedure starts.

What Directors Should Do When Rescuing a Business from Insolvency

Document Every Trading Decision After the Insolvency Trigger

From the moment you suspect the company is insolvent, your board minutes are the record a future liquidator will read. Note each question, such as whether to take an order or pay a supplier, and the answer you reached.

Then note why that answer served creditors as a whole. The defence to wrongful trading is that you took every step you should have to cut creditors’ losses. Minutes written at the time are the best evidence of that.

Stop Selective or Connected-Party Payments Immediately

A company problem becomes a personal one when you keep paying the creditors who matter to you. That might be the bank because of your guarantee, the supplier you need next week, or your own loan account, while HMRC waits.

Section 239 can reverse those payments where the company wanted to put that creditor in a better position. The law presumes that wish for anyone connected to you. From the point of insolvency, only make the payments you need to keep trading.

Get a Licensed Insolvency Practitioner’s Written Opinion Before Filing Anything

Get the opinion in writing, and get it before the next board meeting. It’s your evidence, if the decision is later questioned, that you took advice and acted on it.

It must come from a licensed insolvency practitioner, authorised by a body such as the Insolvency Practitioners Association or the ICAEW. Our guide on what an insolvency practitioner does explains who’s qualified.

Be wary of unlicensed “company rescue” firms that charge an upfront fee or suggest moving the business into a new company cheaply. A cheap transfer can be reversed under section 238, and you’d still have the debts. If the company goes into insolvent liquidation, section 216 of the Insolvency Act 1986 restricts you from reusing its name in a new company.

I’d be wary, too, of anyone who promises a CVA will write off most of your debts before they’ve seen your figures. What creditors accept depends on what the business can afford, and on what they’d get if it closed.

Tell Your Bank and PG-Backed Lenders Before They Find Out Themselves

If you’ve given a personal guarantee, the lender will hear about a CVA proposal or an administration as soon as it’s sent out. Tell the lender first, with the rescue plan and the practitioner’s opinion, so that you can discuss the guarantee before a formal demand arrives.

We check what you’ve signed personally before we talk through any route. A guarantee can make the cheapest route for the company the most expensive one for you.

Mistakes Directors Make When Trying to Rescue an Insolvent Business

Treating a CVA as a Discount Coupon

A CVA isn’t a way to write off old debt and carry on as before. It’s a contract with creditors lasting several years, with contributions the company has to keep up. A licensed insolvency practitioner, called the supervisor, oversees it.

If the company can’t keep up the contributions, the CVA usually fails. The company then tends to end up in the liquidation it was trying to avoid, with the cost of the failed CVA on top.

Drawing the Director Loan Account Down to Zero “Just in Case”

Taking money out in the last months because the worst seems to be coming is an easy mistake to make. It can be salary, dividends or repayments of money you lent the company.

Repaying a director’s loan while the company is insolvent is a textbook preference if liquidation or administration follows within two years. Dividends paid without enough profits are unlawful and can be recovered too.

My advice is to stop repaying your own loan account until you’ve had advice. A liquidator or administrator will look for those payments and can pursue you to repay them.

Selling the Best Bits to a Connected Buyer Without a Valuation

A sale to a connected buyer isn’t unlawful. A sale at an undervalue is different, because section 238 lets the court reverse it if the company later enters administration or liquidation. An independent written valuation is your best evidence that the price was fair.

In a pre-pack, the administrator must explain the sale to creditors. Since 2021, a sale to a connected buyer in the first eight weeks also needs creditor approval or an independent evaluator’s report.

Filing an Online Strike-Off to Avoid the Process

Being insolvent doesn’t by itself stop a company applying to be struck off under section 1003 of the Companies Act 2006. However, every creditor must be sent a copy within seven days, and any of them can object.

No application can be made while a winding-up petition is pending, a CVA proposal is live or the company is in administration. A struck-off company can be restored by creditors, and its directors can still be investigated and disqualified.

Related Insolvency Rescue Guides

Frequently Asked Questions About Insolvency Rescue

Will I lose my personal assets if my limited company goes through an insolvency rescue?

What happens if creditors reject the rescue plan?

Does Administration always mean I lose control of the company?

How can I tell if my company is insolvent without instructing a professional?

What if I am already facing a winding-up petition?

Are there government schemes that help rescue an insolvent business?

How long does an insolvency rescue process take?

Does a CVA require shareholder approval as well as creditor approval?

Can directors be held personally liable for trading while insolvent?

How should I communicate with employees during a rescue process?

If the rescue fails, what happens to me as a director?

Check How Serious the Position May Be

Answer four short questions to see how urgent the situation may be and which broad options could fit.

Check my company’s position

Estimates are fineWe only call if you ask us to

Related Guides