What Are Preferential Payments? A UK Director’s Guide Under the Insolvency Act 1986

Understanding preferential payments, as outlined in the Insolvency Act 1986, is crucial for UK company directors facing financial distress or liquidation.

Preferential payments refer to transactions that prioritise certain creditors over others, which can be lawful or unlawful.

Lawful preferential payments are made to creditors such as employees or HMRC, who have statutory priority. However, unlawfully favouring a creditor over others can lead to scrutiny by liquidators and potential risks for directors.

By clarifying these issues, directors can manage creditor obligations fairly and lawfully, thereby avoiding breaches of duty.

Definition and Legal Context Under Insolvency Law

Preferential payments, as defined under the Insolvency Act 1986, are transactions that unfairly favour one creditor over others, breaching the principle of equal treatment among creditors. The Act outlines a strict hierarchy for distributing a company’s assets during insolvency, ensuring fairness and legal compliance.

Certain creditors, such as employees and HMRC, are classified as preferential creditors and are legally entitled to priority in payment. Employees’ claims for unpaid wages and holiday pay fall under this category, as do specific taxes collected by HMRC, such as VAT and PAYE. These payments are legitimate and required by law.

Conversely, making payments that place one unsecured creditor in a better position than others is unlawful. Such actions can lead to clawback by a liquidator and pose significant risks for directors. Ensuring equal treatment of all creditors is not merely a legal duty, but also a safeguard against personal liability and misfeasance claims. Directors must navigate these obligations carefully to uphold their responsibilities and protect their position.

Why Liquidators Investigate Preferential Payments

Liquidators investigate preferential payments to ensure fairness among creditors during insolvency. Their primary duty is to examine transactions made by a company leading up to insolvency, scrutinising bank statements, creditor schedules, and payment histories to identify any suspect transactions that may have unfairly favoured certain creditors over others. This upholds the principle of equal treatment among creditors, a cornerstone of UK insolvency law.

If a liquidator identifies a payment that appears to be unfairly preferential, they can recover those funds. This may involve applying to the court to reverse the transaction, effectively clawing back the payment into the company’s insolvent estate. Such actions ensure that all creditors are treated equitably according to the statutory hierarchy of payments. Additionally, liquidators may pursue legal actions against directors if these transactions suggest misconduct, further safeguarding the interests of all creditors involved.

Common Examples in UK Liquidations

In UK liquidations, preferential payments unfairly favour one creditor over others. Repaying directors or their family members ahead of other creditors is a typical example. Such transactions can raise concerns, mainly when the company is nearing insolvency. Similarly, paying HMRC out of turn without a valid reason can be considered preferential, particularly if it disrupts the statutory payment order.

Here are typical scenarios that might be viewed as preferential payments:

• Repaying Directors or Family Members: Prioritising loans or debts owed to directors or their relatives can be seen as an attempt to protect personal interests over those of other creditors.  
  
• Paying HMRC Ahead of Others: While HMRC has secondary preferential status for certain taxes, paying them ahead of other creditors without justification can lead to scrutiny.  
  
• Settling Unsecured Creditors Selectively: A liquidator might challenge a decision to pay off an unsecured creditor over others without a clear commercial rationale.

Even well-intentioned payments can attract investigation if they disrupt the equitable treatment of creditors. Directors must ensure that all payments align with the legal framework to avoid potential clawbacks and personal liability.

Risks and Consequences for Directors

Directors who improperly make preferential payments face significant risks, including personal liability, misfeasance claims, and potential disqualification. When a company is insolvent, directors must treat all creditors fairly. Failing to do so can lead to serious repercussions.

A significant risk is personal liability. If a liquidator identifies an unlawful preferential payment, they can pursue a misfeasance claim under Section 212 of the Insolvency Act 1986. This could result in a court order requiring the director to repay the misapplied funds or compensate the company’s assets.

Another consequence is director disqualification. The Insolvency Service may seek a disqualification order if a director’s conduct is deemed “unfit.” This can prevent them from managing or being involved in any company for up to fifteen years.

Additionally, creditors may seek to claw back funds to ensure equitable distribution. Any preferential payments could be reversed, impacting the director’s financial standing.

Key risks include:

• Personal Liability: Directors may be held accountable for company debts.  
• Misfeasance Claims: Legal action for breaching fiduciary duties.  
• Disqualification: Bans on future directorships.  
• Clawback of Funds: Reversal of payments to restore fairness among creditors.

Understanding these risks underscores the importance of adhering to legal obligations and seeking professional advice when insolvency looms.

How to Avoid Potential Liabilities

Directors should maintain clear and contemporaneous records of all transactions to minimise the risk of personal liability when insolvency looms. This documentation is crucial in demonstrating that payments were made for legitimate business reasons and not to favour certain creditors unfairly.

Seeking professional guidance early is equally important. An experienced insolvency practitioner can provide invaluable advice on navigating financial distress and ensuring compliance with legal obligations. Engaging such expertise at the earliest sign of trouble can help prevent inadvertent breaches of duty.

Another key measure is keeping creditors informed. Regular communication can foster trust and may provide opportunities for negotiation or revised payment terms. Documenting the rationale for each payment decision is also essential. This transparency will support your actions if a liquidator later scrutinises them.

Practical Steps If Insolvency Is Likely

If insolvency is likely, act swiftly to protect your position as a director. Create a detailed cash flow forecast to understand your company’s financial health and identify immediate pressures.

Stop any payments that could be seen as preferential or questionable, such as those to directors or family members. Ensure all creditors are treated equitably to avoid legal issues.

Consult an insolvency practitioner promptly for expert advice tailored to your situation. They can guide you through insolvency law complexities and help you fulfil your duties effectively.

Here’s a brief checklist of immediate actions:

• Create a Cash Flow Forecast: Identify financial pressures and plan accordingly.  
• Stop Questionable Payments: Avoid preferential payments to ensure fair treatment of all creditors.  
• Consult an Insolvency Practitioner: Seek expert guidance to understand your obligations and options.  
• Maintain Transparency: Keep open lines of communication with creditors and stakeholders.

Seeking Professional Advice

If you’re worried about potential preferential payments or your company’s financial position, it’s vital to seek professional advice without delay. At Company Debt, we’ve guided thousands of directors through financial difficulties, helping them understand their obligations and explore practical solutions.

A licensed insolvency practitioner (IP) plays a crucial role in this process. Their expertise in UK insolvency law ensures directors remain compliant with the Insolvency Act 1986, while also providing a safeguard against personal liability or misfeasance claims. By consulting with an IP early, directors can treat all creditors fairly, negotiate effectively, and document decisions properly—protecting themselves against future challenges.

Don’t leave it too late. Use our live chat during business hours or call us on 0800 074 6757 for immediate, confidential advice from our team of insolvency specialists. We’re ready to help you take the right steps and reduce the risks associated with financial distress and liquidation.

Preferential Payments FAQs